In Canada, this principle is foundational to human rights and affirmed in law. Diverse sexual orientations, gender identities, and gender expressions represent natural human variations deserving of full legal protection, dignity, and bodily autonomy. While federal legislation formally repudiates the premise that queer and trans individuals need “repairing,” significant disparities persist between statutory protections and the lived experiences of vulnerable groups, especially 2SLGBTQ+ newcomers, asylum seekers, and individuals with precarious immigration status (Lee, 2019; Lee & Brotman, 2011).
The Legal Standard vs. Everyday Exploitation
Canada’s Criminal Code prohibits conversion therapy nationwide under Bill C-4, classifying attempts to suppress or alter an individual’s sexual orientation, gender identity, or gender expression as criminal conduct. Despite legal bans, empirical research demonstrates that conversion practices continue to affect sexual and gender minorities in Canada, with disproportionately high exposure observed among immigrants, racial minorities, and transgender individuals (Salway et al., 2021). Within immigration and settlement networks, systemic barriers and precarious legal status create vulnerabilities that bad-faith actors exploit:
- Underground conversion practices: Unregulated practitioners, religious figures, and community gatekeepers have subjected newcomers to clandestine conversion or suppression practices, often leveraging community isolation, family dependency, or fear of deportation to enforce compliance (Salway et al., 2021).
- Extortion, workplace abuse, and sponsorship coercion: Migrants on employer-specific work permits or tied family sponsorships face severe structural vulnerabilities (Lee, 2019). Predatory employers and sponsors exploit this reliance by withholding documentation, underpaying wages, or threatening deportation if an immigrant discloses their sexual orientation or gender identity.
- Retaliatory reporting and housing insecurity: Precariously housed or undocumented 2SLGBTQ+ migrants face landlords and informal employers who violate labor standards and tenant protections, using threats of Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) intervention to silence victims from seeking police or legal remedies (Lee, 2019).
Systemic and Institutional Hurdles
The vulnerability to underground abuse is further intensified by systemic hurdles within administrative and settlement structures:
- Evidentiary burdens in refugee adjudication: Claimants seeking protection on the grounds of sexual orientation, gender identity, and gender expression (SOGIESC) frequently confront skepticism, Western-centric expectations of “coming out,” and invasive credibility assessments during Immigration and Refugee Board hearings (Lee & Brotman, 2011).
- Gaps in institutional settlement and municipal protection: Fear of CBSA entanglement prevents victims from reporting violent crimes, hate incidents, or illicit labor practices, as access to public services and safe policing remains unevenly applied across jurisdictions (Lee, 2019).
- Settlement sector silos: Newcomer settlement organizations frequently lack specialized resources or culturally competent environments for 2SLGBTQ+ individuals, leaving migrants dependent on community structures where heteronormative pressures may be severe (Lee & Brotman, 2011).
Real safety requires moving beyond nominal legal protections to dismantle the structural precarity that allows underground exploitation to occur. Every 2SLGBTQ+ newcomer, worker, and asylum seeker deserves equal dignity and the freedom to live openly without fear of coercion.
References
Lee, E. O. J. (2019). RESPONSES TO STRUCTURAL VIOLENCE: THE EVERYDAY WAYS IN WHICH QUEER AND TRANS MIGRANTS WITH PRECARIOUS STATUS RESPOND TO AND RESIST THE CANADIAN IMMIGRATION REGIME. International Journal of Child, Youth and Family Studies, 10(1), 70–94. https://doi.org/10.18357/ijcyfs101201918807 Cited by: 66
Lee, E. O. J., & Brotman, S. (2011). Identity, Refugeeness, Belonging: Experiences of Sexual Minority Refugees in Canada. Canadian Review of Sociology/Revue canadienne de sociologie, 48(3), 241–274. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1755-618x.2011.01265.x Cited by: 287
Salway, T., Juwono, S., Klassen, B., et al. (2021). Experiences with sexual orientation and gender identity conversion therapy practices among sexual minority men in Canada, 2019–2020. PLOS ONE, 16(6), e0252539. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0252539 Cited by: 89